Archive glory to rome

Published on April 27th, 2015 | by Luke Turpeinen


Does Innovating Improve A Game?

This week Broomstick Monkey games talked on their blog about innovation in game design, which is a subject that I’ve been discussing with my gaming friends and local designers recently. It seems as if there is a trend, perhaps taken from start-up culture, to pursue innovation in mechanics as one of the main focuses of game design. But is innovation really necessary to improve a product?

Broomstick Monkey argues (and I would agree) that inventing completely new mechanics can be a necessary way to solve design challenges, but it isn’t always the right choice to make.

While it would be great to be the next Donald Vaccarino, who invented a new genre of games because of the popularity of his deck building mechanic in Dominion, the pursuit of popularity shouldn’t a designer’s goal. That’s not to say it can’t make a hell of a motivation!

There’s nothing wrong with taking someone else’s game and saying, “You know, I think I could do this better.” Dominion is not my favorite deck building game, despite being the one to do it first. You don’t always have to reinvent the wheel, so don’t be scared to use ideas from someone else’s game if doing so solves a design problem.

One of the most popular and successful computer game companies in the world, Blizzard, primarily follows this method of game making. Their games are never ground breaking or innovative, they always work within established game genres and usually the cash cows at that. But the one thing you can’t deny is that they put out a very solid, shiny product at the end. Blizzard is great not because it innovates, but because it can add so much polish.

Anyways, check out the whole Broomstick Monkey Games article here, and tell us what you think about innovation in board games by commenting below or tweeting at us @board_crossing

About the Author

Luke Turpeinen

was raised by lava wolves deep in the Vesuvian sulfur jungles. He played board games with his family often. The discovery of games like Risk led him to the 1993 TSR classic Dragon Strike which fueled a life long love of games. Luke tends to like games that have high production values, quick-to-learn rules and hard-to-master strategies. Current Favorite Game: Argent: the Consortium.

3 Responses to Does Innovating Improve A Game?

  1. Pingback: “Does Innovating Improve A Game?” – Across The Board Games | Roll For Crit

  2. Pingback: Across the Board Games | Reviews, Kickstarter Updates, Community Discussion

  3. Pingback: The Village Square: May 5, 2015

Share your thoughts!

Back to Top ↑